Difficulties in using references which 2nd year English majors face when doing secondary research (SR) in Hanoi University

In brief, with this project, we carried out the difficulties in finding, evaluating and integrating references in doing secondary research of second English majors at Hanoi University. It is obvious that using references in doing secondary research is no easy task. However, this survey does not give students obstacles which make them feel difficult to use references. It makes student pay attention to difficulties to be careful when using references not only in doing secondary research but in other research as well. Our project was done on small scale and small aspect so cannot void some limitations. We hope that further research will be done to enlarge this topic.

doc8 trang | Chia sẻ: EngLishProTLS | Lượt xem: 1554 | Lượt tải: 0download
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu Difficulties in using references which 2nd year English majors face when doing secondary research (SR) in Hanoi University, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
t this. Within the scope of our project, we investigated difficulties in using references which 2nd English majors face when doing secondary research to clarify what makes it hard.
 Materials and Methods
	In order to gather data for our study, a questionnaire (see Appendix) was designed. The very first question is to identify students’ opinion about using references. The next question is mentioned about common places where they often gain information for secondary research. Whereas, the third and forth aim to probe difficulties in finding references. The subsequent one concentrates on difficulties in evaluating references. Lastly, the rest of questions are figured out difficulties in integrating references.
	Second-year English students at Hanoi University were participants of our research. 30 students were chosen randomly from different classes. Most of them are female and at the age of 20 on average. Their attendance was purely voluntary.
	The survey was implemented in Hanoi University in April, 2009. The questionnaires were distributed to the participants in each class in the break time. Firstly, the students read the questions carefully. Then they were explained with some unclear points. They fulfilled the questionnaires for 30 minutes. After that, we collected all the handouts.
 Results and Discussion	
	In general, almost students consider using references as a difficult task. The fact is that 70% of asked students find it difficult, 30% of them find it normal and no one finds it easy. In this study, the distribution of facts relate to difficulties in using references is conducted. It will make clear why students feel it difficult.
1. Difficulties in finding references
1.1 Time consuming
Table 1: Time consuming to find references
Spending time
Not much
Much
Very much
The number of respondents 
1
3%
20
67%
9
30%
	The first things we figure out about difficulties in finding references are time consuming. When being asked about time, 20 of 30 respondents answer that they spend much their time on finding references, 9 of 30 respondents spend very much their time on that and only 1 person report that finding materials does not cost their time much. These numbers indicate that finding material is a task which require much time. Masson stated, “There are seventy million books in American libraries, but the one I want to read is always out” (As cited in Atkinson, R. H. (1999), p.416). Hence, to follow by a set amount of time for writing is not easy for them.
1.2 Other difficulties
	Because writing a research paper is not limit the data resources, participants can look for materials from a variety of sources. However, the majority of their information gathering is found in Hanu’s library (42%) and on the Internet (47%). Only some percentage they report that they have information from friends, teachers or other people (8%) and have materials from other libraries (3%). Based on this numbers, we can focus on the difficulties of finding materials in Hanu’s library and on the Internet. To be more specific, we categorize difficulties into printed sources (mainly in document room of Hanu’s library) and electronic sources (mainly on the Internet).
1.2.1 Difficulties in document room of Hanu’s library
	Bar-chart 1: Frequency of facing obstacles in document room	
	It can’t be denied that many students have troubles with printed source in Hanu’s library. As illustrated in bar-chart 1, the students’ responses show how often they face with “shortage of materials” and “being unable to find relevant materials”. A half of respondents (50%) often face with shortage of materials, 12 respondents (40%) sometimes face with shortage of materials and only 3 respondents (10%) rarely face with shortage of materials. There is no stick that fall into “never”. This number indicates that shortage of materials is difficult for more than half of respondents. Moreover, the percentage of students having problem with finding relevant materials is higher than shortage of materials. More than a half of respondents (57%) are sometime not able to find relevant materials and 40% of them are often unable to find relevant materials. These difficulties are mentioned above associated with the variety books in library and students’ ability to work with sources.
1.2.2 Difficulties on the Internet
Bar-chart 2: Frequency of facing obstacles on the Internet
	As be shown in bar-chart 2, lack of computer skills is not big problem compare to problem with some websites and slow internet connection, 47% sometimes, 40% rarely and 13% never face with. Trouble with some websites (such as messy, inaccessible and unprinted) and slow internet connection seem have the same rate. There were only 5 respondents (17%) rarely meet these obstacles, the rest of them (83%) sometimes or often meet. Searching Internet hides some obstacle which is hard to avoid. Messy website is an example for that. “The Web is messy in that it cannot always provide clear directions on how to get where we want to go. The hyperlinks that exist among different Websites often send people on a trip to nowhere or somewhere totally unexpected” (Herd, 2006). And for some websites, students are asked for money to access. In addition, some website they can access but they cannot copy or print. Finally, slow internet connection is problem wide common. In the computer lab, because there are a large number of students accessing Internet at the same time, Internet connections are sometimes slow. The fact is that the more people access Internet in the same network, the more slowly it is.
2. Difficulties in evaluating references
Table 2: Frequency of facing obstacles in evaluating
How often do you face with these following obstacles when evaluating references?
Never
Rarely
Sometimes
Often
Have a lot of new words
0
3
21
6
Not fully understand author’s opinion
1 
4
20
5
Gather out-of-date materials
1 
9
18
2
Gain one-sided materials
0
7
19
4
Take too much time to read
1
2
6
21
	The table above shows how frequency students face when evaluating references. As we can see, a number of respondents answer that they are “sometimes” and “often” for “have a lot of new words”, “not fully understand author’s opinion”, “gather out-of-date materials”, “gain one-sided materials” and “take too much time to read” are 27, 25, 20, 23 and 27, respectively. And these are big number for each category. 
	In doing secondary research, students have to gain many materials. But “not every thing that is published is accurate, worthy of your respect, or credible” (Benander, 1999, p.306). Hence, that they sometimes and often meet these obstacles cannot avoid. References with relevant time will be more persuading the readers and one-sided materials can make the readers go another ways. Therefore, they have to spend time to care about that. If the materials have many new words, surely, they have to spend more time to read. Particularly, if they read carelessly, they can misunderstand author’s opinion. 
3. Difficulties in integrating references 
3.1 Difficulties in avoiding plagiarism 
	Bar chart 3: Plagiarism
	Plagiarism (using sentences or ideas of an author without acknowledging) is not a strange thing with students. As shown in bar chart 3, sometimes makes up the highest percentage (70%), follows by rarely (17%), often (13%) and never (0%). Students use paraphrase most (50% of respondents apply paraphrase most when integrating) but they still use sentences or ideas of an author without acknowledging. It means that students are based on the reference materials too much. To avoid plagiarism in this situation is wide difficult for students. It requires the whole progress of learning and the important thing is that students have to be aware of avoiding plagiarism.
Other difficulties
	Bar-chart 4: Frequency of facing obstacles in integrating
	No respondents answers that they don’t face with lack of vocabulary and grammar. They meet these obstacles rarely (17%), sometimes (63%) or often (20%). Benander (1999) said that “The greater the variety of words the writer knows, the greater the ability he or she has to express an idea exactly and completely” (p.266) and “Grammar is perhaps the most intimidating concept a student of writing faces” (p.23). In fact, students need use vocabulary and grammar to express authors’ ideas in their own words, to introduce references in research. Therefore, that up to 83% of respondents sometimes and often face with lack of vocabulary and grammar is absolutely clear factor which cause difficulty in integrating references.
	Additionally, being afraid of making mistakes is another difficulty of students which account for sometimes (30% of respondents) and often (30%). Students scare making mistakes means that they scare integrating and writing. “Almost all writers at some time suffer from a fear of writing or a feeling of being unable to write” (Benander, 1999, p.2). This may call is difficulty of concentration.
	Moreover, 40% of students often face with difficulties in finding main ideas when summarizing equal to rate of sometimes. This difficulty is easy to understand because when summarizing, they need report the work of others without unnecessary detail.
 Conclusion
In brief, with this project, we carried out the difficulties in finding, evaluating and integrating references in doing secondary research of second English majors at Hanoi University. It is obvious that using references in doing secondary research is no easy task. However, this survey does not give students obstacles which make them feel difficult to use references. It makes student pay attention to difficulties to be careful when using references not only in doing secondary research but in other research as well. Our project was done on small scale and small aspect so cannot void some limitations. We hope that further research will be done to enlarge this topic.
Word count: 1610

File đính kèm:

  • docbai_viet_7791.doc
Tài liệu liên quan