Exploring Teachers’ and Students’ Perceptions of and Attitudes Towards the use of Blogs for English Writing Skills at a Vietnamese University
The study aimed at finding out: i) the attitudes of both teachers and students at a
Vietnamese university as regards the integration of blogs into English writing classes; and ii) their
perceived advantages and difficulties in adopting such a way of teaching and learning. Data was
collected in two stages: a preliminary questionnaire survey with 110 students and 12 teachers of
EFL (English as a Foreign Language) writing, and follow-up interviews with 07 participants, both
teachers and students. Findings indicated participants generally held a positive attitude toward the
integration of blogs into EFL writing curriculum. Significant benefits in adopting a blogging
approach included teachers’ and students’ access to computer and the Internet, their ability to
handle blog-related technical issues, and their awareness of the possible benefits of a blogintegrated curriculum. However, the current limited use of blogs for practicing English writing at
the institution as well as students’ willingness to post their writings and give feedback on a public
page were among the major obstacles. The study was concluded by some important pedagogical
implications for the realization of a blog integrated EFL writing curriculum in Vietnam.
VNU Journal of Science: Education Research, Vol. 36, No. 4 (2020) 36-49 36 Original Article Exploring Teachers’ and Students’ Perceptions of and Attitudes Towards the use of Blogs for English Writing Skills at a Vietnamese University Nguyen Thanh Mai1,*, Dat Bao2 1School of Foreign Languages, Hanoi University of Science and Technology, No.1 Dai Co Viet, Hai Ba Trung, Hanoi, Vietnam 2Faculty of Education, Monash University, Australia Received 04 April 2020 Revised 13 April 2020; Accepted 13 April 2020 Abstract: The study aimed at finding out: i) the attitudes of both teachers and students at a Vietnamese university as regards the integration of blogs into English writing classes; and ii) their perceived advantages and difficulties in adopting such a way of teaching and learning. Data was collected in two stages: a preliminary questionnaire survey with 110 students and 12 teachers of EFL (English as a Foreign Language) writing, and follow-up interviews with 07 participants, both teachers and students. Findings indicated participants generally held a positive attitude toward the integration of blogs into EFL writing curriculum. Significant benefits in adopting a blogging approach included teachers’ and students’ access to computer and the Internet, their ability to handle blog-related technical issues, and their awareness of the possible benefits of a blog- integrated curriculum. However, the current limited use of blogs for practicing English writing at the institution as well as students’ willingness to post their writings and give feedback on a public page were among the major obstacles. The study was concluded by some important pedagogical implications for the realization of a blog integrated EFL writing curriculum in Vietnam. Keywords: Blogs, blogging approach, blog-integrated curriculum, EFL writing, Vietnamese university. 1. Introduction * The innovation of Information and Communications Technologies (ICTs) over the past decades has brought about intensive _______ * Corresponding author. E-mail address: mai.nguyenthanh@hust.edu.vn https://doi.org/10.25073/2588-1159/vnuer.4402 changes in roughly every aspect of our modern life and has prompted education to search for ways to successfully integrate technological advances into its curricula. Up to now, a multitude of studies worldwide have been conducted on the integration of blogs, an application of web 2.0, into language teaching and learning. Specifically, the positive outcomes of contemporary [1-4] have N.T. Mai, D. Bao / VNU Journal of Science: Education Research, Vol. 36, No. 4 (2020) 36-49 37 strengthened educational practitioners’ belief on the use of blogs as a high-yielding tool in foreign language teaching and learning. The worldwide influence of ICT innovation, to some extent, has raised Vietnamese educational researchers’ awareness of the necessity to speed up ICT integration in education and training, yet research into the employment of ICTs for academic purposes in general is still in its early stages, not to mention the specific area of English language teaching (ELT). The first and very few studies targeting ICT applications in ELT in Vietnam included those carried out by Nguyen [5, 6], which discussed technology-enhanced EFL (English as a Foreign Language) syllabus design and materials development, and Dang & Robertson [7-9] which studied EFL students’ autonomy and e-behaviours through their participation in a web 2.0 Moodle site. However, available studies have not yet specifically addressed the use of blogs in the teaching and learning of EFL writing at tertiary level. The study, therefore, aims to explore the attitudes and perceptions of teachers and students at one of the public universities in Vietnam regarding the integration of blogs into English writing curriculum. The two major research questions include: i) What are teachers’ and students’ general attitude towards the use of blogs in English writing classes at the university? ii) What are the possible advantages and difficulties in adopting this way of teaching and learning English writing skills? 2. Literature Review 2.1. Benefits of a blogging approach in the teaching and learning of writing skills 2.1.1. Blogging improves language writing performance Studies on the influences of blogging on language writing have concluded that blogs can facilitate and enhance the instruction of academic writing [10], resulting in greater improvement in students’ writing performance compared to mere in-class writing instructions [11, 12]. From a quantitative point of view, Mompean [13] noted that “the number of contributions was quite satisfactory as the students posted more messages than the number originally required and this can be interpreted as a sign of involvement in the project” (p.389). Also through blogging, language learners further develop their intercultural competence [3], activeness in reading [14], vocabulary base and background information of the foreign language [15], and most importantly, writing fluency [2, 16]. Because of the asynchronous nature of blogs, students have more time to reflect on the content and write without any time pressure [17]. That explains why there tends to be more open and better expression of self among online learners than when they are on the more traditional pen-and-paper mode [18]. Another reason for students’ personal development in writing has been attributed to the meaningful and diverse interactions that they are involved in while participating in blog activities [3]. 2.1.2. Blogging fosters language learners’ understanding and personal growth The construction of weblog broadens the context of classroom interactions [19] by minimizing the limitations of time and space [20], therefore encouraging students’ deeper understanding and individual, critical voices in their writings. When blogging, each student plays two roles of a speaker/writer and an audience and is actively involved in a social process with meaningful and reciprocal interactions. As writers, student bloggers have opportunities to interact and negotiate meaning in the target language with authentic audiences, ones that are closely connected to the meanings generated both in oral and written form [21]. As consumers of blog posts, many students appreciate anonymity, a feature of blogs, as a chance to critically review and challenge their peers’ writings, something they may not find easy and comfortable to do in a face-to-face context [22]. N.T. Mai, D. Bao / VNU Journal of Science: Education Research, Vol. 36, No. 4 (2020) 36-49 38 On top of that is the instructor’s vital role in providing linguistic feedback and promoting students’ own views and capacity for self- critique and self-reflection [2, 17, 20]. Although blogs are not considered ‘real-life,’ the multidirectional interactions among student bloggers, teachers and anyone else happen to view the blog posts are meaningful, because “they make sense for learners who are fully engaged in the writing process and in the interactions” [13]. In their recent study, Jimoyiannis and Tsiotakis [4] concluded that the enhanced opportunities for managing individual work, peer feedback and interaction, supportive dialogue and reflection, sharing ideas, critical thinking and metacognition, all positively influence the students’ writing quality. 2.1.3. Enhancement of motivation through various authentic language activities Blogging helps learners become more involved in writing through a wide range of authentic activities, i.e. those having relatively equal cognitive challenge and complicatedness as real-life tasks [23-25]. Take Galien & Bowcher’s [1] study as an example. The diverse cultural background of their students was well catered for in the blog activity, which, under the broad topic of “High schools around the world” students were asked to write descriptive paragraphs to exchange their high school experiences. Thanks to this, the writing task became directly relevant and motivating to students. Other examples of authentic tasks can also be found in the blog-integrated curriculum designed by Lee [17]. In one task, students were encouraged to reflect on a topic of their own interests or concern. Another task asked students to choose certain podcasts in the language they were studying to listen to (e.g. Facebook or eating out and fast food) then write an entry to describe the content and explain some new words or phrases they found interesting. Involvement in authentic tasks like these helps build up learners’ confidence and motivation in learning, for they have some control over their learning. The students in Lee’s research were also allowed to use multimedia (e.g. external links, photos, and YouTube videos) to support the text content. As a result, over 80% of participants preferred blogging to the traditional mode of writing. Similar findings were observed in the study by Huang [3] where students reported higher motivation as they could choose their own topics and were able to incorporate writing into real life. All in all, the employment of authentic blog activities complies with adult learning principles put forward by Brundage & MacKeracher (cited in [24]): “adults learn best when the content is personally relevant to past experience or present concerns and the learning process is relevant to life experiences.” 2.2. Challenges of a Blog-integrated Curriculum Although much of the existing literature on blog-integrated curricula has been about the benefits, some studies did discuss the difficulties that teachers and students faced as they took up a blogging approach in their writing class. For example, Petersen et al [26] found certain students would refrain from posting their works on blogs due to shyness. Besides, publicly commenting on their peers’ writing is another thing that students may not be willing to do, not only because it is a demanding task that requires skills and practice [27] but also because, for certain cultures (usually Asian), people are not encouraged to directly criticise their peers [22]. Apart from these, the use of blogs in writing classes may also come with typical challenges of any ICT-integrated curriculum. There have been concerns about teachers’ confidence with as well as students’ access to and affinity with computer and the Internet, especially the gap between those living in big cities and those in the rural area [28, 29]. On top of that is how to encourage teachers’ consistent use of technology as a teaching and learning tool as technology-enhanced lessons would require extra planning time and greater workload [30, 31]. N.T. Mai, D. Bao / VNU Journal of Science: Education Research, Vol. 36, No. 4 (2020) 36-49 39 3. Methodology Data was collected in two stages, using two different research techniques. Stage 1 (Questionnaire survey) involved 110 EFL students and all 12 teachers of writing skills at the Faculty of Foreign Languages of a public university in Hanoi (Vietnam). The students were selected from 6 out of the total 11 first- and second-year classes using one-stage cluster random sampling [32], in which each class was considered a cluster or a collective unit consisting of approximately 20 single units, i.e. students. The questionnaire survey aimed to find out: i) teachers’ and students’ experience with computer and Internet in general and blogs in particular; and ii) their attitude towards the integration of blogs into EFL writing. The questionnaire was of closed- ended type, but for each question there is one option called “Other” that allows for any answer other than those suggested or further clarification of a chosen answer. Based on preliminary results in stage 1, three students and four teachers were purposefully selected for stage 2 (in-depth interview) using one of the following criteria: - Having prior experience with blogs (preferably using blogs for practicing English) and willing to join the new approach of teaching and learning EFL writing; or - Having prior experience with blogs but not willing to join the approach; or - Having no prior experience with blogs but willing to join the approach. The interviews were conducted to further explore participants’ prior experience with blogs as well as highlight the possible advantages and difficulties in adopting a blog integrated writing curriculum. 4. Findings and Discussion 4.1. Attitudes Toward a Blog-integrated Writing Curriculum Statistical data highlight welcoming signals from both teachers and students (89%) regarding the use of blogs in English writing skill. None of the teachers refused to take part in the new approach, and only three out of 110 surveyed students showed negative opinion to blogging in writing. Table 1. General attitudes toward the integration of blogs into EFL writing Options Teachers Students No. % No. % Opinion towards the integration of blogs I’m interested in and would love to try I don’t want to try I can’t decide Other: (02 comments) 11 0 01 91.7 0 8.3 97 03 10 88.2 2.7 9.1 d A very small number of participants, i.e. one teacher and 10 other students, were still considering the adoption of blogs. However, from the teacher’s further comment in the questionnaire, she was more likely to hold a positive rather than negative attitude toward the proposed curriculum: “It seems to be an interesting approach, especially in the context that students are very quick in updating new technologies and many of them are keen on free writing. However, I need to find out more about this approach before deciding to give it a try. For example, whether it is feasible for the majority of students? Whether there are any difficulties for teachers? Whether teachers can control and assess students’ learning? Whether any research has been conducted to verify the effectiveness of blogs in writing? Etc.” Her explanation demonstrated a cautious attitude toward making a choice in how to learn rather than following the trend. Indeed, her considerations of the feasibility and other aspects of the approach turned out to confirm N.T. Mai, D. Bao / VNU Journal of Science: Education Research, Vol. 36, No. 4 (2020) 36-49 40 the significance of the research, as these were indeed what the study was set out to explore in the first place. Also, in the questionnaire survey, another teacher expressed her willingness to adopt blog application in not only writing but also other subjects: “I think it’s worth trying blogs in writing skills. Gradually we can expand this model to other subjects. Each week teachers post topics on a class blog for students to discuss and comment, and their interactions on blog can be counted as participation”. This pattern of attitudes was consolidated by data from the in-depth interviews. Hoang, the youngest teacher and a former student of the Faculty, said enthusiastically: “if there is such a writing curriculum, I will be the first to join”. Similarly, Quoc, a first-year student, asserted his full support of bringing blogs into English writing: “ I’m willing to participate once it [the curriculum] is implemented, since this helps promote students’ familiarization with Internet environment and the use of written language to express themselves.” The fact that most teachers and students at the Faculty held positive attitudes toward the employment of blogs in EFL writing subtly implies that they perceive this type of instruction as worthwhile to be adopted. As the direct recipients of the proposed blog-integrated curriculum, a positive attitude among students is particularly important, since it determines their engagement to the online learning environment as well as their language outcomes [33, 34]. The more students believe in the benefits that the online environment could bring about, the greater sense of community they experience [35] and the more active learners they will become [36]. 4.2. Possible Advantages in Adopting Blogs in EFL Writing 4.2.1. Easy access to computer and the Internet Survey data indicated the number of students having access to computer and the Internet accounted for very high percentages (99.1%). Among them, 31.8% had 6 to over 10-year experience with computer, 41.8% had been using computer from 3 to 5 years, and only 26.4% had less than 2-year experience. Moreover, learners could access the Internet from various locations: at home (85.2%), in the dormitory (16.75%), at public access points (13%), and at the Faculty (7.4%). These figures allow for greater confidence in the realization of the integrated approach to EFL writing in the future. The statistics also proved that the EFL teachers at the Faculty had no problem accessing to the facilities needed for the blog approach to writing. Specifically, all 12 teachers had access to computer and Internet, 9 of whom had been using computers from 6 to 10 years and the other three had experienced computers for over 10 years. Teachers could also access the Internet from different locations, for example, at home (100%), at school via the Faculty’s wireless system (7 teachers), at public access points like Wi-Fi cafés (3), and in the dormitory (1). Internet access was even made easier and ubiquitous with the convenience of 3G/4G mobiles and D-Com 3G USBs. Overall, the availability of facilities among teachers of the Faculty was undoubtedly an advantage in implementing any ICT-integrated curriculum. 4.2.2. Ability to handle blog-related technical issues In terms of technical issues, participants who had some prior experience with blogs reported that they did not encounter any remarkable difficulties in using this application. Hoang recalled his early experience as a student blogger: “I found using blog rather simple. My friends introduced that blog page for me, then I learned to manage it myself.” Bao (a freshman) and Thi (a sophomore) both considered blog as one kind of popular knowledge they could pick up easily: “ blogs are designed in a way that many people can easily take up. That is universal knowledge, so I can teach myself how to use. N.T. Mai, D. Bao / VNU Journal of Science: Education Research, Vol. 36, No. 4 (2020) 36-49 41 Anyway, if something comes up, I can always search for instructions from the Internet” (Bao). The actual experience of these teacher and students underlines the user-friendly nature of blog, and therefore the feasibility of the blog- integrated curriculum. What teachers need to do to ensure a higher chance of success is to provide students with some brief pre-training on preferably blog’s technical features and conceptual basis [37] as well as its function in the writing course and in students’ own learning [38]. Hoai pointed out a simple solution: “We’ll look for students who are competent in computer technology in each class and ask them to help with the training.” Hoang asserted that such training did not need to be complicated but covered only the basics: “The most important thing is to help students establish and manage their own blog page. I believe they can learn very quickly under the assistance of their friends and guidance from the teacher.” Invo
File đính kèm:
- exploring_teachers_and_students_perceptions_of_and_attitudes.pdf